Comparative study of apatite formation on CaSiO₃ ceramics in simulated body fluids with different carbonate concentrations

Apatite formation on CaSiO₃ ceramics was investigated using two different simulated body fluids (SBF) proposed by Kokubo (1990) and Tas (2000) and three sample/SBF (S/S) ratios (1.0, 2.5 and 8.3 mg/ml) at 36.5°C for 1-25 days. The CaSiO₃ ceramic was prepared by firing coprecipitated gel with Ca/Si = 0.91 at 1400°C. The bulk density was 2.14 g/cm³ and the relative density about 76%. The two SBF solutions contain different concentrations of HCO₃ ^- and Cl^- ions, the concentrations of which are closer to human blood plasma in the Tas SBF formulation than in the Kokubo formulation. The pH values in the former solution are also more realistic. The CaSiO₃ ceramics show apatite formation in SBF (Kokubo) after soaking for only 1 day at all S/S ratios whereas different phases were formed at each S/S ratio in SBF (Tas). The crystalline phases formed were mainly apatite at S/S = 1.0 mg/ml, carbonate-type apatite at 2.5 mg/ml and calcite at 8.3 mg/ml. At higher S/S ratios the increase in the Ca concentration became higher while the P concentration became lower in the reacted SBF. These changes in SBF concentrations and increasing pH occurred at higher S/S ratios, producing more favorable conditions in the SBF for the formation of carbonate bearing phases, finally leading to the formation of calcite instead of apatite in the higher HCO ₃ ^- ion concentration SBF (Tas). Apatite is, however, formed in the lower HCO ₃ ^- ion concentration SBF (Kokubo) even though the Ca and P concentrations change in a similar manner to SBF (Tas).